Tuesday, 18 September 2012

Rupert Everett, gay dads...and life as a little pink gladiator


Gay dads – good or bad thing? Silly question? Well following Rupert Everett's comments in the Sunday Times, this week the media has dared to ask it.

Taking part in a phone-in on Kaye Adams’ morning show on BBC Radio Scotland this morning, I found myself flailing in a sea of anti-gay-dad sentiment, courtesy of a succession of callers for whom Mr Everett’s unease about children being brought up by two men seems eminently sensible.

I did my best, ably assisted by a gay adoptive dad, the daughter of a lesbian couple, and Ms Adams herself, to make the point that it’s the quality of the parenting, not the gender (nor, dare I say it, sexuality) of the person delivering it, which matters.

This key insight - based, as pointed out by Patrick Strudwick in the Guardian, on a growing evidence base - only ever seems to come up in the media when a gay celebrity becomes a mum or dad, or makes a comment about gay parenting; or when there’s some kind of panic about lesbians having babies and the ‘death of the father’.

In fact, child development experts are increasingly clear that gender’s probably less important than we think in parenting - whether in a gay or straight context. Professor Joseph Pleck argued some time ago that if you’re looking for something uniquely male about the value of fathers’ parenting, for example, you’ll struggle to find it. Dads, like mums, are all different. What’s likely to be most important about all of them is their competent, confident, sensitive hands-on parenting from Day One.

So what? So while non-heterosexuals’ parenting may seem like something other, it in fact offers a springboard into an altogether bigger, more mainstream debate about gender in families (much needed in Scotland, if today's phone-in callers are anything to go by!).

Unfortunately, the media isn’t much interested in that. The TV and newspapers love nothing more than men being from Mars and women from Venus – a dichotomy that feeds effortlessly into pretty much all their coverage of family life (and most of the advertising that supports it). Mothers need to be soft, gentle, ‘natural’ parents…fathers harsh, awkward and ultimately…well, useless and a bit optional.

With that as the backdrop, it is of course fascinating to ponder how on Earth the gay version of parenthood (for there must, needless to say, only be one!) could possibly work, especially since lesbians all look like bikers and gay men just want to dance around to show tunes!

So until the media shifts from its simplistic and sensationalist stereotypes on gender, gay parents will carry on being cast to the lions from time to time – like little pink gladiators fighting the corner for modern, balanced and involved mother- and father-hood. Ah, life at the leading edge...Rupert, you just don't know what you're missing!





Thursday, 16 August 2012

Why not 'proudly sponsor' dads too?

Now the Olympics is finished, does that mean an end to Procter & Gamble's horrid 'Proud Sponsor of Mums' campaign too? Please say yes!

Don't get me wrong, it's a great idea for an ad campaign. And it's as brilliantly executed as one might expect a huge international company, whose brands includes Fairy, Pampers, Max Factor, Ariel and Gillette, to produce. The mums' stories are great.

But come on guys, should a company of your size and reputation be so narrowly focused on mothers (presumably because research shows they're the ones who buy most of your stuff) that you'd miss such a big opportunity to also celebrate the many fathers and father-figures who work their fingers to the bone to help their children become Olympians? 

Monday, 28 May 2012

Saving fatherhood from the bureaucrats' airbrush

It's one thing picking to bits how dads are represented, as I try to do in this blog - but sometimes the problem is that they're not represented at all.

The Telegraph's story about Scotland's Ready Steady Baby leaflet is an example of where a public authority has taken the decision to airbrush fathers out of the picture altogether. Seeking to erase one of the two most clearly understood labels through which we make sense of family relationships is apparently justifiable in the name of equality for same-sex couples who have children.

Says who?! Certainly not the children. If you're a man or woman in a parental relationship with a child, that child knows you as some kind of dad or mum - regardless of what they call you and certainly regardless of your sexual orientation, or whether or not you live with and/or are in a relationship with the child's other parent or parents. Mums and dads are grown-ups who look after you and love you with all their heart. Some people have more than one mum, some have more than one dad - some have a collection of both. Many call them something different, but they know exactly who and what they are and mean. Unlike bureaucrats, kids get this stuff.

And in my experience, most families that involve same-sex parents (including my own) get it too. Of course we need to think carefully about how we use language, and there's no doubt that words like 'father', 'mother', 'mum' and 'dad' contain baggage and can be used to shore up 'traditional' modes of thinking.

But heaven save us from 'parent', that catch-all refuge from controversy fast-becoming the mot du jour of the dead-handed bureaucrats!






Tuesday, 13 March 2012

How to lose customers and offend half the world's parents in one easy lesson

Massive congratulations to Chris Routly, a daddy blogger from Pennsylvania whose petition against Huggies' demeaning 'Dad Test' advertising campaign forced Kimberly-Clark (Huggies' multinational owners) into an embarrassing turnaround.

The original campaign was based on the idea that Huggies nappies could withstand the ultimate test - that of being put on and taken off by fathers...who are of course completely incompetent fools.

Yes folks, an idea this sexist, patronising and ridiculous got through whatever processes exist at this huge international company, and was deemed perfectly ok to unleash on the unsuspecting consumers of America.

Thanks to floods of complaints and Mr Routly's petition, the company decided to adapt its campaign. You can read about the whole sorry tale in the Washington Post and on Mr Routly's own blog, Daddy Doctrines.

You really couldn't make this stuff up, could you?


Friday, 2 March 2012

My new favourite stuff

Sometimes you stumble across a website and it sends a shiver down your spine. Like you've turned a favourite corner. You're in the right place, in safe hands...they're talking your language.

A while ago it happened to me with Pink Stinks, Abi and Emma Moore's awesome campaign about the 'pinkification' of girlhood. Today it's happened again, as I've just found Crystal Smith's Achilles Effect, which argues for a similarly de-stereotyped vision of boyhood.

While I'm on this subject, if you haven't already done so, DO read Cordelia Fine's Delusions of Gender, which sets out to debunk the supposed science behind sex differences. It's brilliant, and if I had my way it would be on the National Curriculum.

None of this is directly about fatherhood, of course - but then again it IS. As fathers (and mothers) we must navigate across oceans of gendered expectation, both of ourselves (informed by the representations of fatherhood we've grown up with) and of our children (through whom new, more inspiring representations will hopefully develop).

Resources like these are precious. They help us recalibrate our moral compasses as we wend our merry way...


Friday, 24 February 2012

Sticking to the formula - Daddy Daycare Episode 2

OK, so the second episode of Daddy Daycare was essentially the same as the first. We know the formula:
  1. Start with a dramatic voiceover pointing out that mums do all the parenting work and dads are useless (this is the same for each episode…just in case anyone were to forget exactly how terrible men are at all this stuff). 
  2. Meet the three dads who are going to be ‘knocked into shape’ – in this episode, one who’s a workaholic, another who doesn’t see nappy-changing as his role, and a third who has five children and can’t cope with their behaviour. 
  3. Meet the long-suffering mothers of their children, and the all-female staff of the nursery where the men will work for a week. 
  4. Light the blue touch-paper and gaze in awe as the men get everything wrong and prove that yes, men really are hopeless. 
  5. Slowly, as the film progresses and the men get space to learn and practise, find glimpses of their ‘inner dad’ shining through. 
Let’s not forget the all-important ‘money shots’ though. This week there were two. One was father-of-five Grant crying his way home, realising how much he’s missed out on by dealing with his own children in too heavy-handed a fashion. The second, a moving conversation between the workaholic dad and one of the nursery workers, who had lost her child to leukaemia at the age of 4, prompting her to change careers so as to care for others’ children. The message – life is precious, don’t take it for granted, spend time with your kids rather than in the office.

So far so obvious. The Fatherhood Institute rightly points out that what’s so desperately lacking in this series is a sense of balance. We already know Episode 3 won’t redress that. Although it does hold out hope of yet more obnoxious stereotyping…one of the hapless victims looks set to be not just useless…but also gay!

Friday, 17 February 2012

Preparing to be unprepared

In stark contrast to Daddy Daycare, A Dad Is Born - also made by Love Productions, ironically enough - offered a sensitive examination of what happens when men become fathers. Kira Phillips' film followed several men as they waited for their babies to arrive, attended the birth and dealt with the first couple of weeks at home.

It was moving to watch the men's fear, their attempts to do their best for their partners and children, and the simple day-to-day caring that is so central to becoming a modern father.

Keeping the ship steady...being there...coping with being unable to take the pain away...feeling the love...thinking about what kind of dad you want to be...dealing with your partner's emotions...wondering how other dads feel...holding it all together...

Reading all the books in the world can't prepare you for new fatherhood - but what this lovely little film showed in spades is that dads need to be open to its hugeness. That's something we in the UK do little to encourage, with our icy-cold ideas about masculinity, our father-blind maternity services and our all-too-short paternity leave provision. High time we put all that right.